How to Model an Option Pool for Startup Employees
Founders at Silicon Valley style technology startups offer their employees stock options. The percentage of the company available to grant to employees as options is called the “option pool.” Modeling the size of an option pool becomes incredibly important when a startup is raising a round of financing, as the VCs will expect the option pool to be large enough to provide options to all new employees who are hired until the next fundraising.
We’ve created a free spreadsheet that founders can use to model out the number of options that they will need. This free option pool model is available on our startup financial modeling page here. Click and then scroll down to see the “Employee Stock Options - VC Negotiation Model” file.
Options dilute the founders
Stock options dilute a startup’s founders’ ownership when the options are exercised and converted into shares of the company’s stock. When employees exercise their options, the number of outstanding shares in the company increases, meaning that each existing share represents a smaller percentage of the total ownership. This reduction in ownership percentage is referred to as dilution.
For example, if a founder originally owns 50% of a company’s shares, and the company grants stock options to employees for 20% of the business (and the options are eventually exercised),, the founder’s ownership percentage will decrease by 20% to 40% of the company.
Therefore, when considering the creation or expansion of an option pool, founders must balance the benefits of providing employees with incentives and the potential dilution of their ownership. And that’s why VCs have founders increase the size of the option pool BEFORE their investment happens.
What about SAFEs and converts? Well, those documents typically have language that have them covert in a way that they are not diluted by the increase in share count from the option pool.
If you are negotiating the option pool size with a VC, check out our article on “the option pool shuffle” which details how to negotiate the pool size. Don’t accidently sell more of your business!
What is the right size for an option pool?
VCs expect founders to set up an option pool that is big enough to assign to all the employees who will be joining a company after the financing round. Founders, on the other hand, would be better off (from an equity dilution standpoint) if the option pool was ONLY increased as new employees were hired.
This sets up a pretty serious conflict of interest. This is a hidden decrease to the effective valuation at a venture round, as the existing investors are forced to decrease their ownership by the amount of the increased option pool PRIOR to the new VC investing in the round.
Founders need to pay special attention to this hidden valuation impact, and should be prepared to negotiate around the size of the option pool needed, just as they negotiate the pre-money valuation!
So the size of an option pool is a negotiation between the founders, the new investors (and usually the existing investors and/or board of directors). From the founders point of view, the smallest to get the round done is best. The VCs will think of the pool as setting aside a portion of the company’s ownership to be distributed to new hires. Therefore, the inventors will say that the size of the option pool should be directly linked to the company’s hiring plan, as it provides a solid foundation for determining its size.
This is the best way to negotiate with VCs about the size of the pool - getting them to agree that the size should be based on the number of hires and how many shares they need.
Then, a smart founder will show a model that allocates options to each new, projected hire. That’s what our free stock option pool model does - it allows founders to list every new hire, by month and title, and then to estimate the amount of options that they will need.
How the option pool decreases the effective pre-money valuation
The VCs expect the founders to ‘eat’ the dilution from the new option pool creation. This effectively decreases the valuation that the VCs offer the founder. For example, if the founder has to create a 10% option pool (pre-money), the valuation is 10% less than what’s on the term sheet! So the modeling of the option pool has a real economic impact on the startup’s valuation.
Don’t forget - many startups already have an ungranted option pool when they are negotiating their next venture round. These ungranted options can be used too, so the option pool doesn’t usually need to be made out of NEW shares, you can use ungranted ones as well.
How to model an option pool
Steps to model an option pool
-
Get our free option pool model here.
-
Enter details of your funding round. You’ll need to enter your desired round size and pre-money valuation. This will be used to calculate the dilution impact of the new shares issued in the fundraise.
-
Create a hiring plan for the new employees.
-
Assign an estimated number of options that each employee will need - it’s easiest to think about this as a percentage of the company.
-
Figure out if you need to top off any existing employees with additional shares (again, think in terms of percent of the company).
-
You now have percent of the company that will need to be granted to new and existing employees after the financing round is completed.
-
Gross up the percent of the company, taking into account the fact that the new investors will dilute the option pool percentage down to the targeted amount. Example math: if you are raising $10 million at a $40 million pre-money valuation, then you are selling 10/(10+40) of the company, or 20%. If you need a 20% sized option pool post investment, you therefore need a 25% sized option pool pre-close. (20% option pool / (1-20% round size) = 25% pool.
-
Know the size of your existing, ungranted option pool. The existing ungranted option pool will reduce the amount of new options you need to create.
-
Subtract the existing pool size from the new pool size needed to come up with the new shares that you’ll need to issue. Use pre-funding percentages. This will be how much extra dilution you’ll get from the new options.
Other stuff on option pools
What are options?
If you don’t know what options are, check out our stock options Q&A. Stock options are a type of benefit that startups often offer to their employees as a form of compensation. They give the employee the option to buy a certain number of shares of the company’s stock at a set price, known as the “strike price”.
The idea behind stock options is to incentivize employees and align their interests with those of the company’s shareholders. If the company’s stock value increases, the employee can exercise their options and buy the stock at the lower strike price, potentially making a profit.
How do you keep track of stock options?
Use a capitalization table - hopefully not in Excel, but instead in a piece of software. We recommend the best cap table software we see startups use here.
About Us
A CPA Firm Specialized in Startup Accounting & Finance
Startups are our niche, and our passion. Our clients have raised over $15 billion in VC funding. We are one of only a few outsourced accounting firms that specialize in funded early-stage companies - we only offer financial and tax services to fast growing startups in the Pre-Seed, Seed, Series A, Series B and Series C stages.
The Right Accounting Partner for Your Startup’s Next Round
We know how to de-risk your startup’s next venture capital round. Our team makes sure you are ready to fly through your next VC’s accounting, HR and tax due diligence. And when you use us as your bookkeeper, we set up and keep up-to-date a due diligence folder so you can get that next round of fundraising.
A Leader in Cloud Accounting Software
Our practice is built on best of breed cloud accounting software like QuickBooks, Netsuite, Gusto, Rippling, Taxbit, Avalara, Brex, Ramp and Deel. Technology makes us more efficient, saving our clients money and letting us offer higher value services like FP&A modeling, 409A valuation, and treasury advice. Startups deserve to work with CPAs using modern software.
Trusted by Top Venture Investors
Top angel investors and VCs refer Kruze because they trust us to give the right advice. Our clients are portfolio companies of top technology and Silicon Valley investors, including Y-Combinator, Kleiner, Sequoia, Khsola, Launch, Techstars and more. With us, your books and taxes are in order when it’s time to raise another round of venture financing.
What types of startups does Kruze Consulting usually work with?
Kruze Consulting works with funded Delaware C-Corps. Our clients have secured Pre-Seed to Series C or Series D funding. We look to partner with our clients, going beyond the typical outsourced accounting relationship and seeking to provide a higher level advisory role. We feel honored to be a part of making the world a better place, even if it’s one debit and credit at a time.
Accounting, Finance, Taxes, & Payroll all in one solution
Startup CFO services, startup accounting and bookkeeping services, startup annual taxes, expense reports, payroll, state sales taxes: we've got you covered. Our software provides custom tailored dashboards that can be provided weekly or monthly, depending on your preference and plan. Founders are often so busy building their company that they don’t have time to take care of their finances. Traditionally, these companies have had to work with a basket of people to get their work done, including bookkeepers, accountants, AP clerks, CFOs, consultants, and tax accountants. At Kruze Consulting, our founders have one point person, saving time and money.
Client testimonials
We're huge fans of Vanessa and the folks at Kruze Consulting. They set up our books, finances, and other operations, and are constantly organized and on top of things. As a startup, you have to focus on your product and customers, and Kruze takes care of everything else (which is a massive sigh of relief). I highly highly highly recommend working with Vanessa and her team.
Vivek Sodera
Co-Founder @ Superhuman
Prior to Kruze, as a remote-first team, we were weighed down by a lot of the bureaucracy involved with having a distributed workforce. Kruze has supported us above and beyond basic accounting needs by ensuring we have everything we need to expand and support our team wherever they may be located
Zack Fisch
Pequity's Head of Operations & Legal
Avochato has been growing rapidly in the past year – in fact, too quickly for us to keep up with books, taxes, and budgeting for growth. Partnering with Kruze Consulting has been fantastic to manage, track, and analyze our finances while we continue focusing on building our customer base. Kruze’s team knows what startups need.
Alex De Simone
CEO @ Avochato
Everybody, go to Kruze Consulting. They do a great job. I personally can tell you, they've done a great job for our companies, including Calm.com. I'm sure they’ll do a great job for you.
Jason Calacanis
Angel investor
